Checked 2026-11-10
What does a trading journal's mistake detector actually look for?
In TradeFlow Quantum, slices of your own trade history that did worse than the rest of it. Once the journal holds 20 trades, the detector groups them by hour and weekday on the US Eastern clock, setup, side, psych score, position size, symbol, the trade after a win or a loss, and your own mistake and emotion tags. A slice with at least 5 closed trades is flagged when its win rate is 15 or more percentage points below your overall win rate, or when it has a negative expectancy, and the 10 with the highest severity are shown. It is arithmetic over your trades, with no model, and it describes what happened rather than telling you what to do.
The gates a slice has to pass
Every flag compares a slice with your own overall numbers, never with other traders. Before it can be flagged, a slice clears these gates:
- The journal holds at least 20 trades, open or closed. Below that, nothing is reported.
- The slice has at least 5 closed trades. Open fills have no outcome, so they count toward neither the slice's win rate nor the baseline.
- Its win rate is 15 or more percentage points below your overall win rate, or its expectancy (net P&L per closed trade) is negative. The second test catches a slice that wins often but loses big: four winners and one large loser can beat your win rate and still lose money.
- A symbol needs 8 trades in its slice on top of that, because one ticker traded a few times is mostly noise.
- Of the slices that pass, the 10 with the highest severity are shown. Severity is the win-rate gap times the natural log of one plus the slice's closed trades, plus one point for every $100 of the slice's net loss, so the same gap on more trades ranks higher.
The slices, one by one
Each flag names its slice. These are the groupings and their labels as the detector writes them:
- Hour of entry, on the US Eastern clock wherever you trade from: pre-market (before 9am ET), opening hour (9-10am ET), mid-day (10am-1pm ET), afternoon (1-3pm ET) and close (3pm+ ET). Trades imported without a time are left out of the hour windows rather than filed at a made-up hour; the date-only answer explains why that happens.
- Weekday of the trading session, on the same clock, so a late-evening fill counts on the day it was traded.
- Setup, by the name you gave it; and side, long against short.
- Psych score: low psych (≤4) for a score of 4 or lower, medium psych (5-6) for a score of 5 or 6. Higher scores and trades with no score form no slice of their own.
- The trade after a loss and the trade after a win. The previous trade has to have closed before you entered, so three entries scaled into one idea that all stopped out together do not count as trading after a loss.
- Position size: the top quarter of your trades by entry price times quantity, with no contract multiplier, compared with your overall numbers.
- Symbol, with the higher bar above.
- Your tags. Each mistake tag and each emotion tag you add to trades is its own slice, and a trade tagged "chased" and "oversized" counts in both.
Plan drift: three checks against a written plan
A trade linked to a pre-trade plan is also checked against that plan, one trade at a time: an exit past the invalidation price you wrote down; a winner closed at 80% of the way to the target or less; and a loss of more R than the plan's maximum risk. These appear on the trade's own page and in a plan-drift section of the weekly digest.
Where flags appear, and what they do not say
Flags appear on the /mistakes page in the app, as a finding on the import screen after a CSV upload, and at the top of the weekly digest email, which goes out every Sunday and opens with "Your biggest leak" and that flag's trade count, win rate against your baseline and total P&L. The /mistakes page also has a lookup: pick a setup, side, hour, weekday or psych range and it shows how your past trades with those conditions did, once at least three closed trades match.
Each flag carries a one-line observation that restates the numbers. It does not recommend a trade, a time or a change. With 5 closed trades in a slice, one trade moves its win rate by 20 percentage points, so a fresh flag is a question to check against more trades, not a verdict. The list of costly trading mistakes covers the habits these slices tend to surface.
For comparison, Edgewonk's features page, read November 8, 2026, says: "No chatbot; the Edge Finder is an automated weekly scan."
Questions traders ask
How many trades before the detector says anything?
20 trades in the journal, and at least 5 closed trades in a slice before that slice is compared with your baseline.
Does a flag mean the setup has no edge?
No. It means that slice of your past trades did worse than your overall numbers by the rule above. With 5 closed trades, one trade is 20 percentage points of win rate, so check it again as the slice grows.
Is it AI?
No. It is grouping and arithmetic over your own trades, with no model. The same trades always produce the same flags.
Why is a trade missing from the hour flags?
It was imported with a date and no execution time. The journal keeps it on the right date but has no hour to file it under, so it stays out of the hour windows while still counting in the other slices.
Sources
Related
- Trades on the wrong day
- Trading mistakes to avoid
- Features
- Why doesn't my trading journal P&L match my broker statement?
- What is a prop firm consistency rule, and how is it calculated?
- Which brokers sync automatically with TradeFlow Quantum, and what does each sync actually import?
- How should a trading journal group multi-leg options trades?
- What happens when I hit a prop firm's daily loss limit: do I fail, or just stop for the day?
- What is a trailing drawdown, and what is the difference between end-of-day and intraday trailing?
- When does a broker connection expire, and how will I know?
- Which broker CSV formats does TradeFlow Quantum recognise before upload?
- Can I import my Tradervue export into TradeFlow Quantum?
- Is my trading journal data backed up?
- Which prop firms lock the trailing drawdown, and where?
- How many losing days can a prop firm evaluation take before it fails?
- What is the profit target as a share of the account at each prop firm?
- What is the minimum number of trading days to pass a prop firm evaluation?
- Can I share my prop evaluation progress without showing my P&L?
- What happens to my trading journal if I cancel TradeFlow Quantum?
- Can I connect my prop firm account (Topstep, Apex, FundedNext) to a trading journal?
- Can I import Robinhood trades into a trading journal?
- How does a prop firm evaluation fail? The rules that end one, and the ones that only delay a pass
- Is there a free trading journal?
- Which brokers import option expirations and assignments into a trading journal automatically?
- Why does my trading journal show my trades on the wrong day, or at 7 PM?
- Does TradeFlow Quantum sync Alpaca automatically?
- Does TradeFlow Quantum sync Charles Schwab automatically?
- Does TradeFlow Quantum sync Tradier automatically?
- Does TradeFlow Quantum sync Tastytrade automatically?
- Does TradeFlow Quantum sync TradeStation automatically?
- Does TradeFlow Quantum sync Tradovate automatically?
- Does TradeFlow Quantum sync Questrade automatically?
- Does TradeFlow Quantum sync OANDA automatically?
- Does TradeFlow Quantum sync E*TRADE automatically?
- Does TradeFlow Quantum sync Coinbase automatically?
- Does TradeFlow Quantum sync Interactive Brokers automatically?
- Does TradeFlow Quantum sync Fidelity automatically?
- Does TradeFlow Quantum sync Robinhood automatically?
- Does TradeFlow Quantum sync Webull automatically?
- Does TradeFlow Quantum sync NinjaTrader automatically?
- Does TradeFlow Quantum sync Sierra Chart automatically?
- Does TradeFlow Quantum sync MetaTrader 5 automatically?
TradeFlow Quantum is a $15/month trading journal: 10 direct broker connections that work during the 7-day trial, nightly sync for paid accounts, a prop-evaluation copilot, and a P&L-free weekly discipline grade. Descriptive analytics only — nothing in the analytics edits your trades.
Start your 7-day free trial →