Compare journals / Edgewonk alternatives
Edgewonk alternatives
Edgewonk and four other journals on the same lines: price, trial and refund, how trades get in, and AI. Each line names the page it came from and the day it was read. We make one of them, so the last section says where ours falls short.
Edgewonk, from its own pages
One plan with everything: strategy checklists, psychology analysis, the Tiltmeter and a weekly automated Edge Finder scan.
- Price
- $197 a year or $35 a month, VAT added at checkout. (edgewonk.com, read Nov 8, 2026)
- Trial and refund
- No free trial; a 14-day 100% money-back guarantee. After cancellation you can no longer log in. (edgewonk.com, read Nov 8, 2026)
- How trades get in
- Auto-sync for MetaTrader 4 and 5 brokers and prop firms; every other platform (IBKR, Schwab, NinjaTrader, Rithmic, Tradovate among them) is a file import. (edgewonk.com, read Nov 8, 2026)
- AI
- No chatbot; the Edge Finder is an automated weekly scan. (edgewonk.com, read Nov 8, 2026)
- Reviews
- Trustpilot: 4.7 from 44 reviews. (www.trustpilot.com, read Nov 8, 2026)
Limits Edgewonk states
- Limit
- No trade replay, no bar-by-bar backtesting and no native app. (edgewonk.com, read Nov 8, 2026)
- Limit
- TradingView imports are paper trading only. (edgewonk.com, read Nov 8, 2026)
TradeZella
Automated journaling with AI review, automated backtesting and multi-account tracking, gated by plan on AI credits, backtest runs and account count.
- Price
- Essential $35/month ($26 billed annually), Pro $59 ($44), Ultra $99 ($74), since July 14, 2026; earlier subscribers keep their old price while they stay on the same plan. (help.tradezella.com, read Nov 8, 2026)
- Trial and refund
- No free trial is mentioned on the pricing page or the pricing help article; a cancelled plan runs to the end of the billing cycle, and the cancellation article states no refund policy. (help.tradezella.com, read Nov 8, 2026)
- How trades get in
- "500+ brokers"; the supported-brokers table marks some as Auto Sync (including Schwab, IBKR, Robinhood, Tradovate, TradeStation, NinjaTrader, MetaTrader) and others as file upload only (including Tastytrade, Webull, Lightspeed, DAS Trader Pro, TopstepX). (www.tradezella.com, read Nov 8, 2026)
- AI
- Zella AI is on every plan with a monthly credit allowance (500 on Essential); its help article says it "can make mistakes". (help.tradezella.com, read Nov 8, 2026)
- Reviews
- Trustpilot: 4.8 from 1,076 reviews. (www.trustpilot.com, read Nov 8, 2026)
More: TradeZella alternatives
TraderSync
A journal with a market-replay simulator and the Cypher AI assistant, gated by plan on replay precision, Cypher messages and accounts.
- Price
- Pro $29.95/month ($22.46 billed annually), Premium $49.95 ($37.46), Elite $79.95 ($59.96). (tradersync.com, read Nov 8, 2026)
- Trial and refund
- Every tier says "Try free for 7 days". The refund policy page would not load for the reader; Trustpilot reviewers report no refunds. (tradersync.com, read Nov 8, 2026)
- How trades get in
- Autosync from supported brokers on every paid tier, plus file import and manual entry; the supported-broker page blocks automated readers, so the count is not confirmed here. (tradersync.com, read Nov 8, 2026)
- AI
- Cypher messages are capped at 5 / 15 / 60 a day by tier. (tradersync.com, read Nov 8, 2026)
- Reviews
- Trustpilot: 4.2 from 326 reviews; the profile says the company has not replied to negative reviews. (www.trustpilot.com, read Nov 8, 2026)
More: TraderSync alternatives
Tradervue
A long-running web journal with sharing and mentor features, reporting on stocks, options, futures and forex; no AI, replay or backtesting on any of its pages.
- Price
- Silver $29.95/month and Gold $49.95/month; the pricing page shows monthly prices only. (www.tradervue.com, read Nov 8, 2026)
- Trial and refund
- 7-day trial with the card charged at the end unless you switch to the free plan; the signup page says "All sales are final - no refund". (app.tradervue.com, read Nov 8, 2026)
- How trades get in
- "80+" platform integrations; in the broker table the Automated column is checked for five rows, and most brokers (IBKR, Schwab, Robinhood, Tradovate, TradeStation among them) import from a file. (www.tradervue.com, read Nov 8, 2026)
- AI
- No AI features on any page read. (www.tradervue.com, read Nov 8, 2026)
- Reviews
- Trustpilot: 2.2 from 11 reviews, profile unclaimed. (www.trustpilot.com, read Nov 8, 2026)
More: Tradervue alternatives
TradeFlow Quantum
A journal that imports from your broker and computes descriptive statistics from your own trades: pattern flags, a P&L-free discipline grade and a prop-evaluation copilot. Nothing writes to your data.
- Price
- One plan: $15/month or $150 a year. (tradeflowquantum.com, read Nov 9, 2026)
- Trial and refund
- 7-day trial, card required at signup. Within 14 days of any charge (the first payment or a monthly or annual renewal), email support@tradeflowquantum.com and we refund that charge in full, no questions asked. After cancellation the journal stays readable and exportable (read-only). (tradeflowquantum.com, read Nov 10, 2026)
- How trades get in
- 10 brokers connect directly, including during the trial; 18 more brokerages through SnapTrade on the paid plan; CSV from any broker. (tradeflowquantum.com, read Nov 9, 2026)
- AI
- No AI chat or AI tagging; every flag is reproducible arithmetic over your own history. (tradeflowquantum.com, read Nov 9, 2026)
- After an import
- After a CSV import or a broker sync, the result shows the mistake detector's strongest pattern in your own trades (closed count, its win rate against your overall rate, net P&L), how many more trades it needs (it compares slices from 20 trades), or that no slice crosses its threshold yet.
- First weeks
- For the first 14 days after signup the dashboard lists four steps, each decided from your own rows: import, reach 20 trades, see the first finding, then tag a trade or write a pre-trade plan.
- Option events
- Option expirations and assignments close positions from the broker's own records on Alpaca and Tastytrade, expirations alone on Tradier (added November 10, 2026; not yet confirmed on a live account). On Charles Schwab and Questrade an expired or assigned contract becomes a journal trade only if you log it by hand. On E*TRADE whether those records reach the journal is not confirmed.
Where ours falls short
- –Fewer broker connections than TradeZella's "500+": 10 direct, plus SnapTrade on the paid plan.
- –No market-replay simulator for practice trading.
- –No reviews on Trustpilot yet.
Moving from Edgewonk
The switch page shows how Edgewonk's export works and exactly which columns carry over. The comparison page sets the two journals side by side, feature by feature.
Vendors change prices and terms without notice; their own pages are authoritative. Trustpilot figures are as shown on the date read. TradeFlow Quantum is not affiliated with any vendor named here.